Former WWE NXT interviewer now playing roller derby

Former backstage interviewer for NXT Kelly Kincaid, formerly Quinn McKay in ROH, is now playing roller derby in the Orlando area.

Kincaid had been with WWE since 2022. She made her debut on an episode of NXT Level Up in February of that year after previously working as Quinn McKay in ROH starting in 2019.

Kincaid announced earlier this year that her WWE contract expired on February 14 and that she was not given the option to renew.

On Saturday, Kincaid posted a statement to Instagram noting that she is finding her identity outside of wrestling again. She wrote that she has gone back to playing roller derby.

Kelly Kincaid’s statement:

“I didn’t have an identity outside of work for eight years. I’ve never had more fun in my life than when I was Quinn McKay at Ring of Honor. I poured my heart and soul into her, and I like to think it showed. But it was an all consuming love, and I spent every waking moment figuring out how to build that character.

WWE was another story. It’s a rewarding, but very demanding, job. Everything I thought I knew about my craft was dissected, analyzed, and turned around. It wasn’t better or worse than what was expected of me at ROH, it was just different. I loved all the moments I spent with you as Kelly Kincaid, even if it was incredibly different than what I would have chosen to give you.

So I guess this is a very delayed thank you for spending those eight years with me. I don’t know if I’ll ever return to wrestling. As we’re told over and over again at the performance center, “it comes for us all”. And I’ve spent the last three months figuring out what that means for me, and how I exist outside that bubble.

I had forgotten who I was while living inside different characters for so long. So I’ve gone back to my roots. I’ve started playing roller derby again. It’s given me my life back. I love my family. I love to riot. I love skating.

I can see just the barest glimpse of who I used to be. If you’re in the Orlando area, come check out a game sometime. It’s like wrestling, but you know… on roller skates. And after four very long years, I’m stepping back into my own spotlight.”

Kincaid is likely referring to Orlando Roller Derby, a flat track roller derby league based in the metro Orlando area. In a separate message, she said her skater name is Buffy Stunners and that she wears number 25. However, it’s not clear what team she skates for. Games are listed as taking place at the Barnett Park Gym at 4801 W. Colonial Dr.

Based on previous social media posts, Kincaid used to play for the Springfield Roller Girls in her hometown of Springfield, Missouri.

Kelly Kincaid says she ‘wasn’t given the option’ to remain with WWE

Image: WWE

A day after announcing that next Saturday would be her final day in WWE, NXT backstage interviewer Kelly Kincaid revealed that it wasn’t her call to leave.

As she announced Friday, Kincaid’s contract is set to expire on February 14 and in responding to a fan asking if it was her choice not to renew, she replied, “I wasn’t given the option.”

The 34-year-old first debuted on NXT Level Up in February 2022 after previously working for Ring of Honor in 2019 as a commentator and interviewer. She also has competed in the ring as Quinn McKay, both for ROH and on the indies, with her last match taking place in December 2021. She’s had 20 matches in her career, according to Cagematch.

Kincaid and injured WWE wrestler Elton Prince welcomed the birth of their first child on September 20, 2024. Prince has been out of action since May 2025 and underwent neck surgery last month.

WWE backstage interviewer announces departure from company

Kelly Kincaid will be departing WWE later this month.

The NXT backstage interviewer revealed on Friday that she will no longer be under contract with the company as of February 14.

“As of February 14th, I will no longer be under contract with WWE,” Kincaid wrote on X.

Kincaid debuted on an episode of NXT Level Up in February 2022. She previously worked for Ring of Honor under the name Quinn McKay beginning in 2019. In addition to her on-air roles as an interviewer and commentator, she also wrestled in ROH’s women’s division in 2021. Her last match on record took place on December 30, 2021 for MCW in Maryland, just weeks before she made her WWE debut.

Kincaid is in a relationship with Elton Prince. The couple welcomed the birth of their first child on September 20, 2024. Prince has been out of action since May 2025 and underwent neck surgery last month.

Elton Prince, Kelly Kincaid welcome birth of first child

WWE’s Elton Prince and Kelly Kincaid are parents.

Poppy Faye Howley was born on Friday, September 20, 2024, the couple revealed in an Instagram post.

The comments section of the couple’s post is filled with congratulations from their colleagues in the wrestling industry:

“Congratulations guys! Best day of your life!” SmackDown General Manager Nick Aldis wrote.

“Omgggg congratulations!! She’s beauty!!” Nia Jax wrote.

“That hair!!!! Congratulations!” Indi Hartwell added to the post.

“Couldn’t be happier for you,” wrote Prince’s Pretty Deadly tag team partner, Kit Wilson.

“Wow congrats!!!” TNA’s Steph De Lander wrote.

“Omg congratulations 😍🥹 she’s beautiful just like her mama,” NXT Women’s North American Champion Kelani Jordan wrote.

“Congratulations to you both,” wrote TNA’s Killer Kelly.

“Congrats to you both!!!!” Wrote ring announcer Alicia Taylor.

“I just love her with all my heart,” wrote NXT’s Stevie Turner.